THE TALKING CURE

Writing this has been difficult…trying to get to the friend-picture part of the essay, while also visiting subjects that have been important parts of my life: social work/being a therapist and conversation. So, it is a long post, but if you keep scrolling (reading too…) you’ll eventually get to some pretty pictures.

In one of my former lives, I was a licensed ‘talk’ therapist. In other words, I practiced psychotherapy (my licensure at the professional entry level). The AI blurb for the National Institute of Mental Health’s definition of “talk therapy” describes it as “a collaborative mental health treatment where you meet regularly with a licensed professional to explore your thoughts, feelings, behaviors, and relationships.”

I found it to be one of the most interesting of all possible lines of work. How could it not be fascinating, listening to tales of obsession, perversion, and delusion involving cleanliness, unusual sexuality, and perceiving glaring faces along every pebble-filled pathway. (In no instance, did any of the concerns reach a place of actual danger, I hasten to add.)

Here’s the rub though. As a therapist, you do not get to share your story. Oh sure, you can bring a smattering of your experiences into the conversation but only if they’re related to helping your clients sort through their issues. Neither do you get to ever ever say to your client, “O.M.G.” nor “Well, that is the dumbest thing, I’ve ever heard” nor “Are you kidding me… you did WHAT!” Etc.. So, while I was a good-enough therapist, I was too mature (or old and set in my ways) and impatient to never express astonishment at people’s misguided, sometimes shockingly so, choices to really settle in as a mental health worker.

In my profession as a human however, there are two kinds of “talking cures.” The one for which I studied social work and the other one that simply (or not so simply) requires conversation. The latter is the most satisfying in one major way…both (or all) participants are on equal footing when it comes to expressing whatever they need or want to express. In conversation, we sort of take turns and we use too many or not quite enough words and our sadness, eagerness, excitement, and/or anger is lessened or increased as our words (and silences) multiply. Conversation is a wonderful thing, at its best something of a panacea or even celebration for and of whatever the world is throwing our way.

October 2026 offered up talking cures for ills I hadn’t even acknowledged yet (for example, an autumnal kind of melancholy). Fortunately, I had several talk therapists of the non-social work/friend type last month, but I will dwell on the out-of-towners because I can’t stop by their ‘offices’ for a pep talk every other day: Tom from Delaware USA and Val from Colombia (Not the District of…).

Fifty years or so ago, I was the night auditor and Tom was my boss at the Albuquerque Hilton on University. Even though I wasn’t particularly adept at night auditing, we established and have maintained an important friendship lo these many years. Then, just over 20 years ago, I was Val’s boss at VSA/North Fourth Art Center. Val, along with May and Jess, formed a lively trio of AmeriCorps teachers and became treasured life-long friends.  

Although, over the years, Tom and I have spent time together in Dover and in Albuquerque, this is the first time he has been my guest; Val stays with me almost every year now, but for much too brief a time. This year was special with Tom here long enough for short road trips with much conversation, and Val here also for a generous serving of talk, talk, and talk, enhanced by May joining us for a round of the best of experience sharing. Along with this wealth of discussion, much bread, butter, tea, coffee, even the occasional wine was shared. It was perfect.

And the point of this informal essay is to reaffirm (if, in the midst of world and technical craziness, we have forgotten) that conversation is one of the most important acts of life, or it can be if we take the time to make it so. It is the brand of talk therapy that, utilized more often by and among people, might make less of the clinical kind necessary.

Before going into more detail (and the promised photos) about the grand visitations of Tom, Val, and May, here is an appropriate article to reference, one I came across just as my conversationally therapeutic October wound down. It was “The Secret to a Good Conversation” by writer Charlie Tyson (The Atlantic, July, 2023).* According to the dictionary, conversation is the “oral exchange of sentiments, observations, opinions, or ideas”, an activity that, according to Tyson, is bandied about these day as being dead, killed, at least partially, by an obsession with our phones. He points out that worry about the decline of conversation is nothing new, from Jonathan Swift citing the “vapidity of upper-class banter” in 1783, to some of today’s games that prompt players with questions and topics for purposes of making conversation. Tyson wonders if ChatGPT will provide us with ready-made discourse in the future.

I am happy to report, based on my October days with the aforementioned out-of-towners that, no, absolutely not, conversation is not dead. In fact, I believe my friends and I practiced that fine art with great zest and pleasure in our days together. According to author Paula Marantz Cohen, whom Tyson often quotes, “Delightful conversation [only] requires mutual vulnerability and a willingness to engage, in unhurried fashion, in the fortuitous rhythms of verbal improvisation.”

Cohen references a Virginia Woolf saying “[Conversation] flies up the chimney and is gone,” claiming that the best conversations surrender to this ephemeral quality, and that understanding the transience of talk can help us speak with one another more deeply. Furthermore, it is “precisely the nonutilitarian and leisurely nature of conversation, that makes it so valuable as a humanizing activity.” Tyson continues, “Conversations, in other words, most often produce nothing. But in the twists of talk, we open ourselves to others and allow our interior to be subtly reshaped.” I love this description and have read it over several times. The idea of the wispy disappearing nature of conversation and yet, we’re left feeling somehow more content after indulging!

October’s ‘Talk Therapy’ continues, first ‘on the road’ with Tom (which involves a whole road trip album) and then girl-talk with Val and May.

Returning to Tom and Val and “Delightful conversation…[that] requires mutual vulnerability and a willingness to engage, in unhurried fashion, in the fortuitous rhythms of verbal improvisation.” Tom and I have two half and two full-days together, the latter intended for forays out into enchanting New Mexico. Tom loves this state with something approaching passion, the same way I have felt for much of my time here. Our first visiting afternoon/evening is made easy by the fact we share ‘mutual vulnerability,’ having known each other and discussed in-person and on numerous phone conversations the ups and downs of our lives: Tom, some deep tragedies; I, smaller fluctuations in life’s passages. Now our shared vulnerability is age; with only a few years separating us, it’s a partially sad topic, but one approached with a certain bravado on both our parts.

Our first morning on the road rolls around and we’re soon up and. It’s so fine, moving out of the city up toward the Jemez mountains and Pueblo. I’m driving, my friendly Focus all clean and shiny with new tires, courtesy of son Scott. What could go wrong? Well, maybe a twinge of wrong, as I am become directionally challenged almost immediately. We super-agers aren’t necessarily good at making the correct turns which seems to be my personal main issue with driving. I’m calm and confident on the road, told in fact by a couple of somewhat disinterested passengers, that I’m an excellent driver. It’s just that I’m sometimes on the wrong road. Anyway, even with our slight befuddlement we’re soon out of town, headed up through the scenic countryside. All is well, almost. At a photo stop the car objects to restarting—which is mildly alarming, having never happened before. But then it does and we’re on to the village of Jemez, stopping at a popular restaurant for lunch. I check the starter and at first it hesitates so a decision is made; we’ll eat and then, assuming the engine turns over after a rest, go back home where we’ll have more conversation time without the stress of being stranded. The problem turns out to be a tired battery; my son springs to action in the morning, replacing it in time for our next adventure.

Nothing makes me feel safer than a bunch of guns and a few dead faces.

The best thing about the New Mexico landscape is that, while we have many mountains, in most areas of the state they are not grand and high and close together; there is space above and around them for far-vistas and plenty of canyons and gorges and trees and villages, and especially excellent cloud art.

We’re up late after so much talking the previous evening, but eventually on the back road to Madrid of mining town heritage and flower-children fame. It has been years since I’ve been there, and Tom hardly remembers it from his New Mexico hotel past. In the meantime, Madrid has upped its cute and touristy vibe over the years, but retains a nice bit of early-hippiedom presence. Another lunch in which Tom must tweak and doctor his New Mexican enchiladas to achieve just the right balance for someone longing for ‘real’ New Mexican food edible by a Delaware chile-sissy.

Included because (in my opinion) we look quite youthful and dashing.

After a story-filled evening sustained by the bread and butter in-home food supply, and time in the morning for one more enchilada food stop…where they finally get it Just Right, Tom is back on the rails. Being a serious train-travel junky, Tom’s touring the US on Amtrak so the trip from and to his ride doesn’t have airport stress factors to deal with.

And about what conversation means: “a willingness to engage, in unhurried fashion, in the fortuitous rhythms of verbal improvisation.” ‘The willingness to engage’ and the ‘unhurried fashion’ parts sound right. I’m not sure Tom and I achieved ‘fortuitous rhythms of verbal improvisation’ but we gave it our best shot.

As I drove home from dropping Tom off at the Amtrak station, it truly felt like I’d just experienced an extra-long therapy session, a feeling of being both at-ease and grounded in life, with a past and present linked by friendship that doesn’t need embellishment, and by a shared desire not to give up on the stuff of interesting lives just yet. Like talking and traveling.

***

Val. Whose life is a little more exciting than the average. Her husband Jon is a PA (Physician Assistant), serving as the head medical officer in many of the smaller or medium-size embassies around the world. So far, they’ve been stationed in Azerbaijan, the Congo (DRC), and now, Colombia, not bad places at all for intrigue and drama. But when I met Val, her life was far less glamorous. She was part of VSA’s first contingent of AmeriCorps volunteers, soon becoming part of the May, Jess, and Val trio, conducting arts activities at VSA and in a variety of social service organization throughout the community. We would have many outstanding artist/and non-artist volunteers over the years so I believe the reason these three stood out to me was their ability to fully enjoy the communities they worked within while building a fine set of interlocking programs…besides which, again like so many of our AmeriCorps volunteers, they were caring, smart, fun, and extremely talented in their own right as artists. After their volunteer year, Val moved on to grad school and May to other work (and happily to work with VSA off and on over the years). Jess served as VSA’s theatre manager and tech director for years before heading out of town. They all married, had kids, advanced in their professional fields and, best of all, we stayed good friends, enjoying so very much ‘talk therapy’ over the years.

Val comes to visit. May comes over. We talk. Which involves many of the same subjects and rhythms that exist in my friendship with Tom. Knowing each other well enough to feel free and safe about who and where we are in our bigger lives. Bemoaning some things, laughing at others. Commiserating and teasing.

And then she’s off again. Part of her luggage being a giant block of cheese, of a kind, Colombia doesn’t stock. Foreign service is hard! I wouldn’t joke if they were still in Kinshasa…

There’s one important friendship component with Val that doesn’t exist with Tom though since he and I are nearly the same age. That’s my appreciation for how much I do simply feel like ‘one of the girls’ with Val and May. Not simply a well-intentioned old lady. We talk animatedly, comfortably. Their work life is present, and they are parents of young/old teens and have partners. But my comments on those topics don’t feel unwelcome even though coming from a less immediate place. Work, family, kids, partners, politics, food, weather, whatever. How to explain: Val and May, in our October time together made me feel like just a regular human being, not a relic from ancient times. And even if they’re being a bit age aware, that’s okay because it’s done graciously rather than condescendingly. Thanks ladies.

To wrap, a final quote from Tyson. “Conversation is commonly called an art, a tribute to the musical rhythms of speech, the gratifications of verbal play, and the ingenuity we enlist when we exchange stories, examine ideas, and evoke images in the minds of our interlocutors. But it is also a craft. In the most blissful conversations, we lay words down like bricks to construct, in turns, an elaborate architecture—structures held up momentarily through the pressure of our attention and imagination. [Then] A phone buzzes; a siren blares; our palace in the air falls to pieces, vanishes into vapor. But we built it nevertheless.”

If I were to discuss conversations with some family and friends who live closer or with whom I talk more through on-line means, I would bring the argumentative possibilities of good conversation into the discussion. With Tom, Val, and May in October, we mostly only had time to “exchange stories, examine ideas, and evoke images”, but what pleasure it was, and what good feelings remain from a month that includes some good talk therapy.

*The gist of Tyson’s article is based on a book, Talking Cure: An Essay on the Civilizing Power of Conversation (Paula Marantz Cohen)

Leave a Reply